Yes, it is a pretty good topic. :)

The only shortcoming is it lasted way too long. haha, my fault primarily!

Yes, it is a pretty good topic. :)

The only shortcoming is it lasted way too long. haha, my fault primarily!



hehe~~my fault, too. also there were several days when huaren was down. anyway, as long as we all had fun~~

Ok, finally I was able to catch up with you guys.
It is really a fun debate to watch. A great topic and a group of people knows how to express their idea. Moreover, the jokes are killing me. :) Aya's Richard Gere joke, the flying pig one. I do think both side present well. Depends on what's you definition on "make". Either side can be a win win.
After reading all posts, my understanding is cloth represents a person(class, style, etc). It doesn't make a person to be who they are. A little cute pig is always a little cute pig, doesn't matter it has feather or not.

oncogenes and teagy [em00]

Very nice. Need to read several more times.

第一次，就算是开个头吧。以后会越办越好的，我相信！

sorry, a bit late...

first my congrats to both sides, great job done~~~

Each side presented, elaborated and defended their topic in a clean and definitive way. Very impressive!!!!

My overall impression is similar to that of coldhan, although clothes do render first impression important but it does not define a person truely. Teagy and oncognes captured the essence and are very persuasive on this part...

My vote would be for teagy and oncognes [em00][em00]!!!!

[此贴子已经被作者于2004-6-5 1:32:58编辑过]

Hello quaint mm,

I have promised you to be a judge. After carfully read all the posts,I feel everybody is great and two teams are both good. The only thing I can see is that teagy's team is a little bit better in "Continuity of argument " . So I consider teagy's team is better. However, I feel my knowledge is limited. I can't give more opinion and hence can't be a fair judge. I have to quit.

Sorry for the mess. I

That's quite OK, hzhch mm! Thank you for your help.
I'll just fill in for you. My comments are coming very soon~~

quaint mm 偶们还等着泥~~~~~